Daylight saving: Is it worth our time and our health?
Depending on which side of the argument you stand, or where you stand geographically for that matter, setting your clock back or ahead an hour can affect you both mentally and physiologically.
It’s the longstanding challenge of shifting from Daylight Saving Time to Standard Time and vice-versa.
On Nov. 7 at 2 am, our computerized clocks will turn themselves back one hour as we make our annual fall return to Standard Time. Standard Time typically runs from the first Sunday in November until the second Sunday in March, which is when we begin Daylight Saving Time by turning our clocks forward again.
Most of us look forward to “falling back,” as we will Sunday morning. But though some people are excited about the extra hour of sleep, the time change may take some getting used to.
“The transition from Daylight Saving Time and back to Standard Time and from Standard Time to Daylight Saving has an impact on desynchronizing our body clock,” said UCLA Chancellor Gene Block, PhD, whose academic research involved the neurobiology of circadian rhythms.
“When you switch from Standard Time to Daylight Saving Time, your body goes through a period of desynchronization, which sometimes leads to a period of malaise where you just don’t feel well.”
Psychological issues linked to re-setting of the clock
Researchers for decades have been split about whether the time changes adversely affect our health. A Danish study from 2017 linked it to the climbing rate of unipolar depressive episodes.
Researchers say seasonal depression, also called seasonal affective disorder (SAD), is directly correlated to the winter’s shorter days and longer nights. Some mental health experts believe there is a related psychological effect associated with the changing of clocks – in that it essentially forces people to acknowledge that longer, darker evenings are ahead.
In similar research, an Australian study documented more male suicides taking place after time changes in both the spring and the fall.
Health issues linked to clock change
- Change in mood
- Depression/Mental health challenges
- Loss of sleep
Effects on behavior and daily habits
Dr. Block compared the time change to changing time zones when traveling. The region of our brain called the hypothalamus recognizes, through our retinas, that there is a new light schedule and it begins to process the information to our internal clock.
“The body is composed of these circadian clocks. They’re like little internal timers. These clocks are located in the cells of your body, in the tissues and the organs,” Dr. Block explained. “Many of these cells go through 24-hour oscillations and these cells are controlled by the hypothalamus, which is the central clock. So, if you fly into France you’re going to reset your watch and the hypothalamus is going to reset too.”
However, setting the clock ahead or back an hour is a little different, Dr. Block said. You are not changing time zones, but you’re changing time and subsequently changing your behavior and daily life patterns in the process. The sun is still coming up at the same time, but you’re eating your meals and waking up at a different time.
It has an effect on animals, too. Dogs and cats may often become confused at the time you are feeding them because they are used to getting fed an hour earlier or later.
Time change linked to changes in traffic, more accidents
Brian Taylor, PhD, director of the Institute of Transportation Studies at UCLA, described how traffic is impacted by the time changes, particularly with Daylight Saving Time in the spring.
“With respect to traffic and safety, there is an elevated crash risk immediately after the time change in the spring with Daylight Saving because people are sleepier and they have to get up an hour earlier,” he said.
Studies indicate the springtime change results in a 6% increase in fatal traffic accidents in the United States. Because of this, some politicians and researchers have been lobbying to do away with Daylight Saving.
In 2018, California voters approved Prop. 7, which would keep the state on a permanent Daylight Saving Time schedule. However, progress has since stalled. Other states have voted on similar ballots to get rid of the biannual clock switch, but they are waiting on the federal government, which is responsible for approving any permanent switches to Daylight Saving Time.
Prepare for the time change
Meanwhile, the debate over the benefits of the time change continues. For every research article that argues in favor of the system, you can find one that justifies getting rid of it.
Arizona and Hawaii are the only two states in the U.S. that do not set their clocks forward or back. However, for the rest of us, time changes are here to stay, at least for now.
Here are some tips to make Sunday morning’s transition smooth:
- Allow your body clock time to adjust by getting to bed a little sooner the night before changing the clock back.
- Increase your exercise regimen a few days prior to the time switch, so you can sleep better.
- Use your time outside by taking walks while the sun is out.
- When planning to drive, leave earlier for your destination, to avoid changes in traffic.